February 05, 2023

The Rolex Submariner Homage Wars: Where the Pagani Design PD-1639 Stacks Up After 6 Months

The Rolex Submariner is the most copied watch on earth. Dozens of brands make homages at every price point. We tested the Pagani Design PD-1639 for six months to see if this $109 entry-level model earns its place among the 100+ Submariner clones currently available.

Let’s be real. The Rolex Submariner is the most referenced, replicated, and revered watch design in human history. Every watch brand you can name - from budget upstart to established luxury house - has made a Submariner-inspired timepiece. There are hundreds of them on the market right now, ranging from $20 fashion watches to $2,000 microbrands to the real thing at $9,000+.

Pagani-Design-PD-1639 Gold Blue

So why would anyone care about another one? What makes the Pagani Design PD-1639 worth your time when there are 50 other Submariner homages priced between $80-$150? After six months of daily wear, here’s the honest, unfiltered assessment.

The Submariner Homage Landscape: Where the PD-1639 Fits

First, let’s understand the crowded field. Here are the major players in the budget Submariner space:

Brand/Model Price Case Size Movement Crystal Water Resistance
Pagani Design PD-1639 ~$109 43mm Seiko NH35 Sapphire 100m
Steinhart Ocean One ~$380 42mm Seiko NH35 Sapphire 300m
Invicta Pro Diver 8926 ~$99 40mm Miyota 8200 Mineral 200m
Stuhrling Original ~$85 42mm Miyota 8215 Mineral 100m
Deep Blue Diver 1000 ~$149 45mm Seiko NH35 Sapphire 300m
Real Rolex Submariner ~$9,000 41mm Rolex 3230 Sapphire 300m

The PD-1639 sits at the absolute bottom of the Seiko NH35/sapphire crystal tier - it’s the cheapest way to get that combination right now. Invicta offers better water resistance for the same price but skips sapphire crystal and uses a lower-quality movement. Steinhart is the gold standard but costs 3.5x more.

43mm Case: Is Bigger Better?

The PD-1639 measures 43mm - noticeably larger than the current Rolex Submariner’s 41mm and much larger than the vintage Submariner’s 36-40mm proportions. Let’s address whether this is a feature or flaw.

Arguments for 43mm:

  • Better lume area (more luminous material on hands and markers)
  • More internal space for the movement (better heat dissipation)
  • Visually prominent - the Submariner is supposed to be a tool watch that makes its presence known
  • Trend alignment - 42-44mm is what most budget buyers expect today

Arguments against 43mm:

  • Doesn’t match the current Submariner aesthetic (41mm is the new standard)
  • Heavier on the wrist (especially noticeable for all-day wear)
  • Harder to fit under shirt cuffs
  • Can look oversized on wrists under 7 inches

My verdict after six months: 43mm is fine for this price point. If you want a 41mm accurate-to-Rolex homage, you need to spend $300+ on a Steinhart or other microbrand. At $109, Pagani Design is prioritizing watch face presence over dimensional accuracy - and that’s the right call for their target audience.

Movement Confirmed: Seiko NH35

After some initial speculation in reviews, I can confirm the PD-1639 uses the Seiko NH35 automatic movement. This is Pagani Design’s standard workhorse and the gold standard for budget mechanical watches:

  • 24 jewels, 21,600 vibrations per hour
  • 41-hour power reserve
  • -20/+20 seconds per day accuracy
  • Both automatic (self-winding) and manual winding
  • Quick-set date at the 3 o’clock crown position

My personal timing results (6 months):

  • Best week: +2 seconds per day
  • Worst week: +18 seconds per day
  • Six-month average: +9 seconds per day

That’s genuinely impressive consistency. For comparison, my Seiko 5 SNXS79 (which I paid $110 for) averages +14 seconds per day. The PD-1639 is outperforming it.

Build Quality: What You Get for $109

Let’s break down the PD-1639 construction honestly:

✅ The Good

316L Stainless Steel Case: Proper 316L surgical-grade stainless steel, powder-coated for the gold color variants and brushed/polished for silver. No pitting after six months of daily wear, including beach use.

Sapphire Crystal: Double-domed, double-sided anti-reflective coating. Not a single scratch in six months. I’ve accidentally bashed it against door frames, desk edges, and even a concrete wall (don’t ask) - the crystal is immaculate. This alone justifies the price over competitors using mineral glass.

Unidirectional Rotating Bezel: 60 clicks, proper ratcheting, ceramic insert on gold colorways. The bezel is tight with no play - critical for a dive watch. Most competitors in this price range have loose, wobbly bezels.

Bracelet: Solid links with proper articulation (each link pivots independently for wrist contouring). The clasp is a simple folding clasp - not a micro-adjustable diver clasp like higher-end models, but it’s secure and easy to use.

⚠️ The Mediocre

Dial Printing: The hour markers and text are printed, not applied metal indices with lume inserts. They look fine from a foot away, but up close you can see the flat print texture. This is a $50 upgrade most buyers wouldn’t notice.

Lume Quality: Super-LumiNova, but not the highest grade. Glows blue, not the green of Rolex’s Chromalight. Glow duration is 3-4 hours from full charge - adequate, but the PD-1679 in the same lineup does significantly better with longer lume.

Date Window: The date window at 3 o’clock has a white background that sometimes washes out against blue or black dials. Pagani Design uses a simple rectangle border, not the magnifying “cyclops” found on Rolex models. Purely cosmetic, but worth noting.

❌ The Bad (Barely)

Screw-Down Crown Threading: The first PD-1639 I reviewed had slightly gritty crown threading (fixed under warranty). The replacement has smooth threading. Quality control can be inconsistent with budget watches - check your crown threading within the first week of ownership.

Water Resistance: 100m Is Honest Marketing

The PD-1639 is rated to 100m (10 bar). Let’s be clear about what this means:

  • ✅ Swimming in pools and oceans
  • ✅ Snorkeling
  • ✅ Showers and rain
  • ✅ Hot tubs (avoid extreme temperature swings)
  • ❌ Scuba diving below 30 meters (the actual limit of 10 bar in practical use)
  • ❌ Professional diving of any kind

This is honest rating. Rolex Submariner is 300m and uses a helium escape valve. Steinhart Ocean One is 300m with proper gaskets. The PD-1639’s 100m rating is exactly what you’d expect for $109 - it’s adequate for real-world water use without overpromising professional dive capability.

Gold Colorway: A Unique Touch

Pagani-Design-PD-1639 Gold Black

One thing I particularly liked about the PD-1639: it comes in a blue-and-gold colorway that mimics the Rolex Submariner Date reference 126618LN (the two-tone gold model). This is a bold, divisive aesthetic that people either love or hate, but it’s cool to see a budget watch offer it. Most Submariner homages stick to black or blue dials with steel cases.

My honest opinion on the gold: The gold PVD coating is durable - no fading or wear after six months. But it’s unmistakably PVD, not solid gold. If you’re buying it expecting solid gold, you’ll be disappointed. If you want the two-tone Submariner aesthetic at a budget price, it delivers.

Six Months of Real-World Testing

Here’s what happened to the PD-1639 during daily wear:

Test Result
Beach wear (saltwater, sand) Rinsed clean, no corrosion
Office wear (suit cuffs) Fits under dress shirt with minor effort
Gym sessions (sweat, impact) Survived, no condensation
Night wear (lume check) Readable for ~3 hours in complete dark
Crown usage (weekly winding) No threading issues after QC replacement
Bezel usage (20+ rotations) Still tight, no play
Bracelet wear (constant use) Minor scratch on clasp hinge, links still articulate

Why This Watch Works (And Who Should Buy It)

The First Mechanical Watch Buyer: You’ve decided to step up from quartz but don’t want to drop $300+ on your first automatic. The PD-1639 gives you a Seiko movement, sapphire crystal, and a legitimate dive watch design at a price where buyer’s remorse is impossible.

The Submariner Curious Collector: You’ve been obsessed with Submariners since you were 16 but know you’ll never own the real thing (or you’d rather spend that $9,000 on a house down payment). The PD-1639 scratches that aesthetic itch without any financial pain.

The “Accidental Damage Fear” Crowd: You’re rough on watches. You work construction, play contact sports, or are just generally clumsy. At $109, you won’t panic if the PD-1639 gets scratched, dented, or lost. It’s a tool watch at a tool price.

The Gold Two-Tone Aesthetic Seeker: You love the Submariner Date 126618LN two-tone look but can’t afford $30,000+. The PD-1639’s blue-and-gold PVD gives you 90% of the visual at 0.4% of the price.

Where the Competition Beats It

To be fair, the PD-1639 isn’t for everyone. Here’s where other homages are better:

Steinhart Ocean One ($380):

  • 42mm (closer to current Rolex sizing)
  • 300m water resistance with helium escape valve
  • Micro-adjustable bracelet clasp
  • Superior lume quality (Super-LumiNova BGW9)
  • Better QC consistency

Invicta Pro Diver 8926 ($99):

  • 200m water resistance (double the PD-1639)
  • Lower price point
  • But: mineral crystal, Miyota movement, poor lume

Deep Blue Diver 1000 ($149):

  • 300m water resistance
  • Seiko NH35 movement
  • Sapphire crystal
  • But: 45mm case is massive for most wrists

Final Verdict After Six Months

The Pagani Design PD-1639 isn’t the best Submariner homage ever made. That title belongs to the Steinhart Ocean One at three times the price. It’s not even the best Pagani Design watch (the PD-1679 has better lume and the PD-1662 has GMT functionality).

Pagani-Design-PD-1639 Gold Black

But it is the best value in Submariner homages at the $109 price point right now. Let’s be specific about what that means:

  • Cheapest Seiko NH35 + sapphire crystal combination available
  • Reliable timekeeping (averaged +9 sec/day over six months)
  • Proper 316L stainless steel construction
  • Decent lume (3-4 hours)
  • Unique gold two-tone colorway
  • Honest 100m water resistance rating

If your budget is $110 and you want a Submariner-inspired automatic watch, buy this. If you can stretch to $150, consider the Deep Blue Diver 1000 for better water resistance. If you’re serious about Submariner accuracy, save for a Steinhart.

The PD-1639 doesn’t win any awards. But it does exactly what it promises: gives you a well-made mechanical dive watch with iconic design DNA at a price point where the decision doesn’t require deliberation. Sometimes that’s exactly what you need.


Enjoyed this article?

Explore more stories from the Pagani Design Journal.

Back to Journal